Section 11. Theses and Dissertation Preparation and Approval
11.10 Thesis and Dissertation Preparation
11.20 Thesis and Dissertation Approval
11.10 Thesis and Dissertation Preparation
11.11. Master's theses and doctoral dissertations to be submitted in partial fulfillment of the graduate degree requirements shall be prepared in accordance with the instructions described in 11.12-11.16.
11.12. Students must comply with the requirements listed in the current issue of the Graduate School Instructions for the Preparation and Defense of Theses and Dissertations. In all cases, students must secure written approval of their proposals on the appropriate Graduate School form before formally starting work on a thesis or dissertation. Students are also responsible for consulting with the Graduate School regarding University requirements and all deadlines related to the submission, defense, and approval of theses and dissertations (see the Graduate School Calendar for listing of pertinent deadlines).
11.13. When preparing theses/dissertations, students are expected to consult with the major professor and members of the thesis/dissertation committee. The student's major professor will be the principal supervisor of the work for the preparation of the thesis/dissertation and will decide, in consultation with the student, which structure will be used. The two structures acceptable for preparation of theses/dissertations are the Manuscript Structure and the Standard Structure. Regardless of the structure used, all theses and dissertations (as well as all course papers, reports, etc.) must be prepared in accordance with the accepted standards of academic integrity, including proper citation and attribution of all material that is not the original product of the writer (also see A. 13).
11.14. The Manuscript Structure consists of the manuscript formatting guidelines published by the journal to which the research will be submitted for publication. If the thesis/dissertation consists of multiple manuscripts, the format of each manuscript must follow the formatting guidelines for the journal to which the research will be submitted for publication. There are a few universal formatting rules that override guidelines provided by journals. These include features such as pagination and margin size and may be found at the Graduate School web site (http://www.uri.edu/gsadmis/thesisdissertation.html).
11.15. The Standard Structure consists of one of several formats for which electronic templates have been prepared. Theses templates are available at the Graduate School web site (http://www.uri.edu/gsadmis/thesisdissertation.html). Each of these templates contains all of the same universal formatting rules referred to in 11.14.
11.16. Theses and dissertations from group research: In most departments, the research that each graduate student performs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for an advanced degree is based on a project planned for one individual under the supervision of a major professor. This project may be a part of a much larger research effort being performed by several persons under the direction of that professor, but each student's research and the thesis/dissertation that results from it is an independent effort performed by that student alone. In unusual cases where the research is less easily separated into individual projects, the quality of performance of any single individual is not measured as easily. In such situations, special precautions must be taken to ensure not only that no student receives credit for work performed by others, but that each student's performance is of the level required for an advanced degree. In group research involving more than one graduate student, each student shall have principal responsibility for a substantial well-defined portion or area of the research project, and shall submit an individual thesis/dissertation proposal and an individual thesis/dissertation in which these responsibilities are clearly defined. In both the thesis/dissertation proposal and in the thesis/dissertation, any work done by another individual shall be clearly identified. A separate thesis/dissertation defense will be conducted for each individual participating in such group research.
Back to Top | Back to Table of Contents
11.20 Thesis and Dissertation Approval
11.21. Establishment of a defense committee: An oral examination in defense of a thesis/dissertation is required in all thesis-based master's degree programs, and in all doctoral programs. To initiate the establishment of a defense, the student must first submit to the Graduate School the name(s) of graduate faculty outside of their program committee who are competent and willing to be nominated as the additional member(s) of their defense committee. For the master's degree, one member of the graduate faculty is needed, usually from a department other than that in which the student is enrolled (see 8.42.3). For the Ph.D., two members of the graduate faculty are needed, one from the same department as the student and one from a department other than the one in which the student is enrolled (see 8.43.4). In both cases, the outside member will normally be designated as chair of the oral defense committee. The student should inform the additional faculty that their name(s) is/are being submitted in nomination to the Dean of the Graduate School who is not restricted in the choice to the names submitted. It should be anticipated that the Graduate School will need a minimum of one week to review this request and approve the membership of the defense committee.
11.22. Authorization to schedule a defense: Once the defense committee has been established, the next step is to secure the approval of every member of the committee to proceed with the defense and to establish a date and time for the defense. Approval signifies that the thesis/dissertation is in a form acceptable for defense and that it is, in fact, defendable. The requirement that the document be acceptable and defendable means that it 1) is complete and contains all text, data, tables, charts, maps, photographs, appendices, full references, citations, and/or bibliographies as required by accepted standards of academic integrity, 2) represents the finished scholarly product of the student's research ready for final printing and in the format required for binding, and 3) is free of obvious fatal flaws that could prevent a successful defense. To initiate the authorization to schedule a defense, the student distributes to each member of the defense committee a copy of the thesis/dissertation they deem to be in final, defendable form. Although there is no prescribed duration for this step of the committee review, two weeks may be thought of as a reasonable target. After each committee member has had sufficient time to thoroughly review the submitted thesis/dissertation, the student will present each member with the Request for Oral Examination in Defense of Thesis form for their signature. This form will include a proposed date and time of the defense. Each member will sign the form if they agree that the thesis/dissertation is defendable and that the time and date are acceptable. Each member has the option of not signing the form if, in their judgment, the thesis/dissertation is not acceptable in style, format, or content for examination purposes and/or if the proposed date and time are not workable. In the event that signatures are not received by every member of the defense committee, the committee discusses the issues that have arisen and advises the student as to the appropriate additions to, or modifications of the thesis/dissertation that need to take place. When a fully signed Request for Oral Examination in Defense of Thesis form is in hand, it can then be submitted to the Graduate School.
11.23. Permission to defend a thesis/dissertation: Prior to the deadline published in the Graduate School Deadline Calendar, and at least 20 calendar days before the earliest date on which the defense is proposed to be held, the student shall submit to the Graduate School sufficient unbound copies of the thesis/dissertation for members of the oral defense committee in a form acceptable for examination purposes. A receipt from Enrollment Services for the binding or microfilming fee, and the Request for Oral Examination in Defense of Thesis signed by every member of the defense committee must also be submitted to the Graduate School at this time. Copies of the thesis/dissertation submitted for defense may contain a reasonable number of clearly legible corrections (printed rather than handwritten), may be printed on paper of lesser quality than that required for the final copies, and may contain pages with only one or two paragraphs. However, these extra paragraphs must be on full-sized sheets of paper and clearly identified and numbered (e.g., 110A, 110B, etc.) in consecutive order with the remainder of the text. Pagination may be in pencil to allow for later revision. Each copy of the thesis/dissertation must be submitted in a separate clasp envelope of suitable size, and shall have a copy of the title page attached to it. In the final copies, type size, paper quality, margins and typed pagination must all conform to Graduate School standards (see Preparation and Defense of Theses and Dissertations).
11.24. Upon receipt of the copies of the thesis/dissertation, the receipt for payment from Enrollment Services, and the request for the oral defense, the Dean of the Graduate School will be responsible for reviewing the student's entire record to ascertain that they have completed all other degree requirements, and that all copies of the thesis/dissertation are in a form acceptable for examination. If the review is satisfactory, the oral examination in defense of the thesis/dissertation will be scheduled and the student will be instructed to proceed as in 11.25 below.
NOTE: Scheduling of oral and written examinations, including qualifying, comprehensive, and defense of theses/dissertations, during the regular summer sessions will be done only at the convenience of the faculty members involved and will be scheduled depending upon the availability of the student's program committee and additional qualified examiners. Examinations will not be scheduled during periods when the University is in recess. Students must be registered for any semester or summer term in which they take an examination.
11.25. Not fewer than 15 calendar days prior to the date set for their oral defense, students shall pick up the copies of their thesis/dissertation at the Graduate School and distribute them to the members of their oral defense committee. Each copy will bear the official notice of the time and place of the oral defense. The chair of the oral defense committee will also be supplied with a copy of the student's thesis/dissertation proposal. The members of the oral defense committee shall examine the thesis/dissertation for evidence of sound scholarship and shall bring to the oral defense written suggestions for changes or corrections in the manuscript.
11.26. All examinations in defense of a thesis/dissertation shall be open to all faculty and students of this University. In exceptional circumstances, as determined by the majority of the examining committee, any of these examinations may be closed.
11.27. It shall be the responsibility of the chair of the oral examining committee to conduct the examination and to provide for changes and corrections to be made in a successfully defended thesis/dissertation before it is given committee approval. A unanimous vote of approval is required for a student to have passed the defense. All members of the oral examining committee also sign the form provided for certifying the student's successful defense of the thesis. When a student's performance is unsatisfactory, one re-examination may be recommended and the conditions under which it is to be given will be stated by the committee.
11.28. Approval of the thesis/dissertation itself will be certified by the signatures of the major professor and the remainder of the research committee on the formal signature page of the thesis/dissertation. These signatures confirm that any changes and corrections to the thesis/dissertation required by the entire defense committee have been made. Only the members of the research committee, not the additional members of the defense committee, sign the formal signature page of the thesis/dissertation. In the event that a student passed the oral examination in defense of the thesis/dissertation denoted by choice 1c or 1d on the oral defense examination form, the major professor or defense chair must obtain the signatures of faculty members who were listed to review the corrections (1c), or the entire defense committee in the event that the thesis was not acceptable as written and required a complete revision (1d). These signatures are to be obtained on a form provided by the Graduate School and then submitted to the Graduate School.
11.29. Final approval of all theses/dissertations rests with the Dean of the Graduate School.
Back to Top | Back to Table of Contents