btn_blue.gif (90 bytes)URI HomeCampusesDirectoriesFast LinksSearchHelp
URI Text Box
Davis Hall
* News Home
* Search Archives
* News Release List
* University Pacer
* About Department
* Staff
orange_line.gif (36 bytes)

Department of Communications/
News Bureau
22 Davis Hall, 10 Lippitt Road, Kingston, RI 0288
Phone: 401-874-2116 Fax: 401-874-7872

U.S. SUPREME COURT REMANDS WETLANDS CASE BACK TO STATE
Rhode Island Sea Grant Provided Scientific Evidence of Wetlands Value to State’s Case

NARRAGANSETT, RHODE ISLAND: -- June 28, 2001 -- A 5-4 U.S. Supreme Court vote remanded back to the Rhode Island Supreme Court Palazzolo v. Rhode Island, determining that the Westerly landowner did not provide enough evidence that his land had been unlawfully "taken" when the R.I. Coastal Resources Management Council (CRMC) forbade him from building on his wetlands property. The court said that the Rhode Island Supreme Court was wrong in determining that Anthony Palazzolo’s case was not ready for review and for ruling that he was barred from making a takings claim because he acquired the property after restrictive regulations were in place. However, the court decided that Palazzolo could have developed one house lot valued at $200,000 on his property, and thus had failed to establish that his property had lost all its economic value. Palazzolo was seeking $3.1 million in compensation for the loss of potential development income.


Rhode Island Attorney General Sheldon Whitehouse appeared before the U.S. Supreme Court on February 26, 2001 to defend the state’s position that a Westerly, R.I., landowner should not be permitted to develop 18 acres of tidal wetlands along the state’s shoreline. At the request of Attorney General Whitehouse, Rhode Island Sea Grant Coastal Extension staff compiled 20 years worth of tidal wetlands research as technical background for the state’s argument.


Recognizing Rhode Island Sea Grant’s long-standing reputation as a national leader in science research and outreach, the state requested assistance in two areas. First, Sea Grant provided quality scientific research that enabled the Attorney General to reference it in both the state’s law brief and science brief for the case. Second, several Rhode Island Sea Grant scientists of national repute who are affiliated with the University of Rhode Island (URI) responded to the Attorney General’s request by submitting a science amicus brief for the case. The scientists are Scott Nixon, Jon Boothroyd, and Frank Goulet.

According to Sea Grant Coastal Management Extension staff, the state sought scientific research about the wetlands area when it built its defense that the Rhode Island Supreme Court had been correct in denying the landowner a monetary award as compensation for being unable to develop his fragile wetlands property. "Rhode Island Sea Grant has a long history of providing exceptional scientific research to decision-making on local, state and federal levels," said Virginia Lee, Sea Grant Extension Coastal Management leader and U.S. programs leader for URI Coastal Resources Center. "Scientific research served a clear role in this case, and Rhode Island Sea Grant was able to respond to the Attorney General’s request for information promptly and effectively."

CRMC had denied Anthony Palazzolo a permit to fill his land for development purposes. Also, the Rhode Island Superior Court denied the landowner’s claim that he should be able to challenge land-use regulations enacted before he owned his property or receive compensation for lost development opportunities.

Established in 1966, Rhode Island Sea Grant is dedicated to increasing understanding of the marine environment and promoting the wise development and use of marine resources for the public benefit.

CONTACT: Rhode Island Sea Grant Assistant Director Ames Colt (401) 874 - 6800
Communications Specialist Sue Kennedy (401) 874-6107

URI Logo

Copyright © 1999
University of Rhode Island
Disclaimer


For more information about this site, contact jredlich@advance.uri.edu
File last updated: Friday, June 29, 2001

The University is an affirmative action/equal opportunity employer. 
All rights reserved. URL: http://www.uri.edu/news/